Online reviews are everything these days. Gone are the times when reviews were just a “nice to have.” Today, they’re a must-have. Nearly 8 in 10 consumers factor reviews into their decision-making process when searching for a local business. But here's the thing: not all reviews are created equal. Consumers—and search algorithms like Google’s—are looking for certain key elements when they assess a business based on its reviews. So, what exactly matters when it comes to online reviews? Let’s dive into the crucial factors that influence how people (and search engines) view your business.
The Average Star Rating: First Impressions Matter
It shouldn’t shock anyone that a business’s average star rating is one of the top things people look at. This number, sitting prominently at the top of your profile, can make or break a consumer’s interest in your business in the blink of an eye.
A higher average star rating screams reliability, quality, and happy customers. It signals that people trust your business and have had positive experiences. On the flip side, a low star rating might as well be a neon “WARNING” sign, telling potential customers to stay away.
Research shows that only 3% of consumers would even consider using a business with a two-star or lower average rating. So, if your star count is tanking, it’s time to rethink your strategy.
Review Sentiment: What Are People Really Saying?
While star ratings are crucial, review sentiment—whether a review is positive or negative—matters too. More than 75% of consumers say that positive sentiment plays a key role in their decision-making. If the review snippet attached to that shiny five-star rating is full of glowing praise, it’s a win. But a negative vibe? That’ll turn people away faster than you can say “bad service.”
Authenticity: Real Reviews Matter More Than Ever
Consumers are savvier than ever, and they can spot a fake review from a mile away. Whether it’s overly gushing praise or suspiciously negative, people are more cautious about what reviews they trust. 62% of consumers say they’ve come across fake reviews in the last year. It’s no wonder that trust in online reviews has dropped—from 79% in 2020 to 48% today.
Platforms like Google and Yelp are cracking down on fake reviews because authenticity builds trust—not just with customers but also with search engines.
Recency: Fresh Reviews Keep You Relevant
Let’s be honest—no one cares about a glowing review from five years ago. 49% of consumers want to see a review from the last month before they feel confident in choosing a business. The recency of reviews matters because it reflects the current state of your service or product. If you aren’t getting consistent feedback, your relevance can start to fade fast.
Responding to Reviews: The Silent Salesman
55% of consumers say that seeing a business respond to reviews makes them feel more positively about the business. Ignoring reviews—whether good or bad—is like leaving money on the table. Google even takes review responses into account for local search ranking. So, taking the time to respond isn’t just good PR—it’s good SEO.
Business responses are an opportunity to engage with customers and show that you care about their experience. Whether it’s a thank-you for a glowing review or addressing an issue in a negative review, responding matters.
Reviews with Photos: A Picture’s Worth a Thousand Words
Images within reviews? Pure gold. 40% of consumers say photos are an essential part of the review process. If you’re running a brick-and-mortar business like a restaurant, hotel, or retail shop, encourage customers to add photos to their reviews. It’s a powerful tool for showcasing what you offer in real life, rather than just through a polished marketing campaign.
Quantity of Reviews: The More, the Merrier
If you’ve only got a handful of reviews, consumers might hesitate to trust the feedback, no matter how positive it is. Think of reviews as crowdsourced credibility—the more reviews you have, the more consumers trust the overall sentiment. High volume also helps ensure that your star rating reflects a broad range of customer experiences.
Visibility Across Multiple Platforms: Cast a Wide Net
While Google might be the king of reviews, having a presence on multiple platforms like Yelp, Facebook, and Tripadvisor is critical. Consumers have their own preferences for which platform they trust, and 78% of consumers research local businesses online at least once per week. Don’t limit yourself to just one or two sites—spread out and diversify your review profile to capture as many potential customers as possible.
In a digital world where visibility is everything, GMB Fox ensures your business isn’t just online—it’s the first choice customers make. Let us handle the complexities of digital marketing, so you can focus on what truly matters: growing your business.
Comments