Let’s face it—if you’re running a business, reviews are everything. They can make or break your reputation in the blink of an eye. With Google Business Profile being the go-to platform for customer feedback, it’s crucial that you manage those reviews properly. But what happens when a review isn’t just bad—it’s flat-out wrong, fake, or simply misplaced? That’s where Google’s new review takedown tool comes in, and today, I’m going to break it all down for you.
Whether you’re dealing with a Karen ranting about her sandwich that was never even ordered at your café, or a genuine case of mistaken identity, this tool has the potential to save your business. But as with everything Google does, there’s a catch. Let’s get into the nitty-gritty of how you can manage your Google review takedown requests, and I’ll even walk you through a real-life case study that might hit closer to home than you think.
The Problem with Reviews: When a Bad Review Isn’t Even Yours
Every business owner knows the sting of a bad review. But what’s even worse? A bad review that has absolutely nothing to do with you. The new Google review takedown tool is designed to help you handle these situations, but it’s not a magic bullet. Before we dive into the steps to report a review, let’s talk about why managing reviews is so important in the first place.
"Businesses can lose up to 22% of their potential customers from just one negative review—this rises to 70% if there are four or more bad reviews," reports BrightLocal. That’s a massive hit on your bottom line, all because someone mistook your business for another.
How Google’s Review Takedown Tool Works (Sort of)
Google’s new tool allows you to remove a review by going through a multi-step process. Sounds simple, right? But here’s the kicker: if you manage more than a few locations, this tool might not be for you. It’s built for small businesses that can afford to click through each review, one by one.
Step-by-Step Process:
Log into your Google Business Profile.
Navigate to the review management section.
Report a problem with the review.
Wait… and wait some more.
Here’s the kicker—Google says it will evaluate the review within 72 hours, but as one of our case studies shows, you could be waiting much longer.
Case Study: The Curious Case of the Wrong Carousel
Imagine running an arts organization, and suddenly people are reviewing your fish and chips. No, this isn’t the Twilight Zone; it’s exactly what happened to Carousel, a non-profit based in Brighton, UK. Thanks to a case of mistaken identity with a nearby restaurant, this non-profit started receiving reviews about soggy fries and crispy cod, not their exceptional arts programs for people with learning disabilities.
These incorrect reviews weren’t just annoying—they were actively harming their reputation. And when they turned to Google’s new review takedown tool, well, let’s just say the process was less than smooth. Reviews sat in “pending” status for months, only to be mysteriously returned to “live” without any email notification.
The Verdict
Google’s new tool? It’s a mixed bag. If you’re a small business with a few reviews, it can be a lifesaver. But if you’re managing multiple locations or trying to fix a serious problem, it feels like more of a half-measure. Google might have released this to say they’re doing something about fake reviews, but the reality? It’s still a bit of a slog.
At the end of the day, you need a strategy—whether that’s manually reporting each review or working with a digital marketing team that knows the ropes.
In a digital world where visibility is everything, GMB Fox ensures your business isn’t just online—it’s the first choice customers make. Let us handle the complexities of digital marketing, so you can focus on what truly matters: growing your business.
Comments